Spencer is A.D. (Uber A) Theory.

So I'm leading towards Spencer being AD. I'm going to start from the beginning and explain why and how.

1) Mary got sent to Radley, because Jessica blamed the death of a child on her. It's not impossible to believe Mary was originally dating Kenneth, before he married Jessica. According to Mary, Jessica was born jealous, and in saying that, it's possible Jessica killed the baby and blamed it on Mary, so she could ruin Mary's life and steal her boyfriend. It is also completely possible, for Kenneth to be Charles' father. She was in and out from 18, she could've slept with Kenneth and got pregnant with Charles. Jessica, probably found out about this, and threatened Mary to stay away from her man. Mary, being scared of her sister, had no other choice.

2) So, as above, we know that Mary Drake was in Radley until she turned 18, then she was let out and occasionally went in and out again afterwards, but why would Mary go back? Let me explain. Mary was originally sent to Radley, because of her sister Jessica, blaming Teddy's death on her. So what would make Mary go back? What about, the death of a child again, which Mary does actually feel guilt over?

3) Who could that child be? None other, than her daughter, Alice. Bethany and Alice were Mary's twin daughters and they lived with Mary and their father, Scott Montgomery (Byron's brother), in the Montgomery house in which Byron now lives in.

Evidence: Look at Bethany's drawing. It looks exactly like the Montgomery house and then take a look at the picture below it. Their kitchen has similarities. (Credit to PLLTheoryMaster)

As we see in the twin flashback, one of the twins kills her sister and then their mother and father walk in to the kitchen, in complete and utter shock and horror and they sent the twin away to a home for the criminally insane (Radley).

4) After the death of one of their daughters, this sent Scott mentally unstable and living with the guilt, eventually turned him suicidal. Mary also felt guilt, guilt over her daughters death, guilt over sending her other child to the place she was sent, so the guilt consumes her and she got sent back to Radley. 5) It is safe to say Mary was afraid of her sister, it would not be a shock if Jessica threatened Mary in some way, to leave behind her two children and never return to Rosewood. So Mary, heartbroken over losing her son to Jessica and then losing her daughter to the hands of her other daughter, decided to leave Rosewood.

6) Bethany could not handle the guilt of killing her own sister, so over time, she developed multiple personality disorder. There were two other personalities, one was Alice (the evil personality) and the other is who we know as Spencer.

7) After a personality battle, Spencer's personality, being the most intelligent and strongest won. Therefore eradicating Bethany's personality completely and making Alice's personality simmer down and fade.

8) With Mary gone, someone had to take responsibility for Spencer, so Mrs DiLaurentis could've struck a deal with the Hastings family. Mrs Hasting's might not have been able to conceive after she had Melissa, so they could've adopted Spencer.

Ok, so there is some of the possible backstory, but now, let's look at some more evidence that implies Spencer could very well be Bethany.

Take a look at the pictures below. The first picture, Is a drawing of a horse by Bethany. Then take a look at the second picture, which is a painting of a horse, hanging up in Spencer's Dollhouse room. Coincidence?

The next picture, courtesy of Analyzing A, shows Spencer and the unknown twin, sharing very similar birth marks. Another coincidence?

Ok, so we've gone through some of the possible backstory and shown how Spencer could actually be Bethany (the unknown twin), but a lot of fans, myself included, have also had very big suspicions about Aria. I'm going to create a theory for Aria, which will tie into this theory.

Only two girls in the Dollhouse had something strange happen to them, other than the usual.

- Spencer had blood all over her body / painting of a horse in her room.

- Aria was made to have her hair dyed back to what it was like when Alison first "went missing." / She also had a framed picture of a mannequin family in her room.

So, let's go with Spencer first. If my theory is true, Aria and Spencer would be cousins. Spencer and Aria are both completely unaware of this. Spencer is unaware, because she's the superior personality of Bethany/Alice. So therefore, only Bethany/Alice personalities would know.

Aria, who was very young at the time, probably assumed they moved away, or Bethany died. It's a 50/50 scenario, as she was a child when the event took place, it's hard to tell if her parents actually told her about what really happened. It's not impossible for Aria to forget over time, I mean, look at Jason. He thought Charles was an imaginary friend. It's entirely possible.

So, why was Spencer covered in blood in the Dollhouse? The easiest answer to that question, is if my theory is accurate, Spencer murdered her twin sister Alice, therefore, the blood all over Spencer is a message. They were trying to force Spencer into remembering who she really is and what she has done. If the Alice personality has come out of Spencer, Alice would be absolutely furious at Spencer. Let's have a look at some pictures, it makes so much sense!

Evidence: The first picture, is when the twin has killed her other twin. The second picture, is something Spencer received from Big A (Charlotte) or Uber A and the third picture, is Spencer covered in blood. We were led to believe it was because Spencer "killed Alison/fake Bethany" but read between the lines a little. Does it not make sense that this is totally not about that?

If my theory is correct, Spencer (as Bethany), would've been in Radley for quite a while as a child and during that time, it's highly possible for the Montgomery family to have visited her. Aria could've been taken to visit her cousin, and this is why Eddie Lamb recognised her. We've all assumed he recongised her because she was a patient before, or because she could be A, but there are plenty of reasons why Aria could've been there. She just generally does not remember visiting her cousin in there.

Now, if Spencer (Alice) is Uber A, she would not be working alone. I honestly believe, if this is correct, Charlotte was just used as a pawn in her game. I believe Spencer murdered Charlotte, because once Charlotte got released, she did not want to play anymore, but the Alice personality did not like this, so she murdered her. Who else could be working alongside Spencer (Alice)? My theory? Wren Kingston. I will tell you why and how it is possible.

Wren's father was mentally unstable and got sectioned to a mental health hospital (Very possible that it was Radley).

It is very possible, that Wren met Bethany inside Radley when they were younger, but he probably met her when her Alice personality was at it's highest point. He and Alice developed a crush on each other, which later turned into genuine feelings.

Now, because Bethany/Alice/Spencer were fighting with each other in Bethany's mind and the Spencer personality won. Wren would've lost Alice. Technically not in body, but in mind and we have heard him talk about an 'ambiguous loss'.

So Wren, being in love with Alice, but with Spencer taken over, decides to leave Rosewood, go and move on with his life in England and study at Oxford. However, deep down in his mind, he still felt the loss of Alice, as she was probably the only one there for him at the time he was mourning his father. He decides to go back to Rosewood after he gains his qualifications and he probably had the plan all along to try and force Spencer into remembering who she really is. He helped Mona and Charlotte when they were A, in hopes that the Alice personality would trigger and come back to him. Overtime, with all the hell Spencer has been put through, it has worked and the Alice personality has resurfaced, who is now working alongside Wren.

See picture below. We assumed this was Charles, but what if it was Wren? "But something about him, felt familiar."

Mary has come back to Rosewood, not only for the money, but because she knows her daughter is unwell again and because she abandoned her the last time, she wants so desperately to try and make up for it. Mary came back to Rosewood and the first person she went to and opened up to, was Spencer. She even dropped twin hints and they looked like they had some kind of connection. It's not impossible for Mary to be Spencer's biological mother. Mary needs the money, so she is going along with Elliot's plan, however, she does not want Elliot to go as far as he's going with Alison, because Alison is still her niece at the end of the day and Mary is not an evil person.

Also, the show has a thing for parallels, take a look at the first photo, with Mary looking at a picture of her daughter, Charlotte. Then take a look at the second photo, is Mary looking at a picture of another daughter? Spencer perhaps?

Now, in Hanna's "dream" with Spencer, Spencer mentions AD, but how does Hanna even know about AD, when the first text message received from AD, was sent to the girls after Hanna was kidnapped? So, was this really Spencer (Alice) and not an actual dream? "A dream is an experience and an experience is REAL."

Also, who was Spencer texting here?!

So, in conclusion;

Amoji = Elliot and Mary

AD/Uber A = Alice Drake (Spencer) and Wren.

Q&A:

Q: Who do you think killed Jessica DiLaurentis?

A: It would be easy to say Mary, but I honestly believe Spencer (As Alice), killed Jessica DiLaurentis.

Q: Who do you think killed Charlotte?

A: Possibly Spencer (as Alice), but I have a feeling, Elliot actually murdered Charlotte.

Q: If Spencer is really Bethany, then who is the girl they found dead?

A: It could be the real Sara Harvey. Something tells me the current one, is a fraud.

Q: If Spencer is Bethany/Alice, why do you think Alice wants to harm the girls?

A: Alice is the evil side of Bethany. Whenever someone with a conscience commits an awful crime, they often feel the need to pass the blame on to someone else, or something else. It was a way of coping for Bethany, but it manifested into a real multiple personality disorder. Think about it, why do all roads lead back to The Lost Woods Resort? When we first saw the motel, it was in a Psycho-themed episode. Psycho is based on a character called Norman Bates, who murdered his mum years ago, but developed a split personality of his mother. The mother side of his personality, kills people and in the end, he was caught and sent to a mental asylum, just like Radley. Alice's motives for the girls, in my own opinion, she wants to take over Spencer and become the superior personality. If she manages to accomplish that, she could do a lot of damage to the girls. She's pure evil. She does not require a reason to harm/kill people. She does it for fun.

Thank you for reading my theory! If you like it, please like my Facebook page and follow me on Twitter - @BeckyChesson

Love Becky

xxx